What’s the utility of options ETFs when the US 10-year yields five per cent?

Covered call ETFs grew in popularity as bond yields stayed low, but issuers argue they have utility beyond just yield

What’s the utility of options ETFs when the US 10-year yields five per cent?

The US 10-year treasury bond yield is, at time of writing, at five per cent. Government of Canada 10-year bond yields are around 3.7 per cent. GICs, as collated by Ratehub offer yields as high as 3.95 per cent for one-year products to 4.5 per cent for five-year products. Five years ago, US and Canadian 10-year treasury yields were barely 1.5 per cent while GICs paid out less than 100 basis points, even on 5-year tenures. The risk-free rate today is significantly higher than it was half a decade ago.

On the surface, that reset in yields should pose a challenge to a set of ETF strategies that grew up in the pre-COVID era of zero interest rate policy (ZIRP) and exploded in popularity during the everything bear market of 2022: covered call option equity ETFs. Their combination of equity exposure, with capped upside, and high income yields became a hugely popular source of cash flow for investors. According to TD securities, Canadian covered call ETF AUM rose from $3.7 billion in 2016 to $57 billion by the middle of 2026. Higher yielding fixed income assets might appear like a new competitive force for these ETFs, but Avinash D’Souza, VP of Product Strategy at Harvest ETFs, says the utility of these products differs enough to still fit next to fixed income.

“In October, covered call ETFs pulled in about $850 million in flows, which is a downtick from September when they pulled in $944 million, according to TD Securities. Now, fixed income is definitely back in favour,” says D’Souza, “Fixed income pulled in $4.3 billion in October, easing off from $4.8 billion in September of 2026. All that to say, I think there’s a higher bar for selection and not necessarily a change in direction. Investors are asking sharper questions around where income is coming from and how sustainable it is.”

D’Souza argues that investors are adding to both their fixed income and covered call exposures simultaneously, rather than switching between the two categories. Core to that thesis, he says, is the different utility of fixed income and covered call strategies.

"Typically, we use covered call ETFs alongside fixed income and not as a replacement," said Adam Liberti, Senior Investment Advisor and Associate Portfolio Manager, TD Bank Group. "A covered call ETF may produce an attractive distribution, and its volatility can sometimes be lower than owning the underlying equities, yet it still carries equity market risk along with it. A bond and traditional fixed income investments serve a different purpose in a portfolio."

Differentiation beyond yield

D’Souza accepts that some of the initial popularity of covered call income ETFs was a product of the low yields offered by fixed income through the 2010s and a need among investors to earn more income from their portfolios. He argues, though, that the equity exposure offered by many covered call ETFs created a different utility for investors. Fixed income, he says, pays investors to leave the equity market while covered calls pay investors to stay in it, albeit with capped upside. Covered call ETFs, he says, tend to fit in the equity sleeve of a portfolio for income-oriented investors, resulting in a dynamic where higher yielding bonds don’t pull assets directly from covered call ETFs.

D’Souza also believes that the wider appetite for income, from covered call equity ETFs, bonds, and GICs, is tied to the persistent and high nature of inflation. The Bank of Canada now expects inflation to rest around three per cent through much of 2027, and investors are looking at higher yielding products as a means of generating cash flows that outpace inflation.

How an ETF issuer plans to compete

Liberti says that, in his view, "every investment has to compete for capital," and that a higher yielding bond market might mean investors don't need as much equity risk to generate the income they need. That said, he doesn't see covered call ETFs as becoming inherently unattractive, simply because their return drivers are so different from fixed income. 

While D’Souza and Liberti think high yielding fixed income can exist alongside covered call income ETFs, D'Souza notes that there are still competitive pressures that his firm faces. He emphasizes, however, that Harvest doesn’t try to compete on yield, framing their products with the software concept of jobs to be done (JTBD). By framing a product around what it does, rather than what it yields, D’Souza says Harvest can more clearly differentiate their products and the wider covered call ETF asset class, from other income investments.

The JTBD of most Harvest products, he says, is in balancing income needs and growth exposure for a level of total return that suits advisors’ and investors’ needs. Ensuring that those ETFs do their job, he says, means focusing more on the sustainability of their income and the nature of their upside trade-offs than on the amount they yield. He says that a focus on utility in client conversations can shift focus from the big yield sticker on an ETF, a GIC, or a bond portfolio onto what the client actually needs.

“Advisors need to basically spell out a couple of things clearly. One, cash flow is what an income investment typically pays you. Total return is what it earns you. Advisors need to understand both,” D’Souza says. “Above all, they need to make sure the investment fits the client’s portfolio. You need to know what job it’s doing.”

LATEST NEWS