Entrepreneur clients might not know how costly a divorce could be

Tea Pupica says that without formalizing value contributions to the growth of a business, a relationship breakdown can prove extremely costly

Entrepreneur clients might not know how costly a divorce could be

Advisors, investors, and the wider public received another object lesson in the negative financial consequences of a business founder’s relationship breakdown last week as extramarital affairs cost Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang his job. While most marital issues don’t normally erase billions in market capitalization, the financial consequences of a relationship breakdown can be uniquely challenging for the founder or owner of a business. Tea Pupica, Business Succession Advisor at TD Wealth, says that the myriad informal ways that a spouse can contribute to the growth of a business makes a divorce potentially nightmarish for everyone involved.

Pupica explained how spouses, even those without formal roles in the business, can contribute significant value to a business. She outlined why a relationship breakdown can then turn questions of contributed value into acrimonious and contentious legal issues, before highlighting what advisors can do to help their business owner clients begin a process of formalization before any relationship breakdown occurs.

“The biggest risk is that so much happens informally in those early days. So when you’re starting a business, you’re focusing on making it work. Family members, they pitch in. They might take on different roles and you don’t necessarily stop to define what everyone is contributing and, more importantly, what they expect in return for that,” Pupica says. “So as that business grows and becomes more valuable, that can become a really big problem because, you know, people have very different views on 4 things: who owns the business, who created the value, who should benefit from it, and who gets to make decisions.”

Defining value contributions

Pupica explains that ownership structure alone doesn’t necessarily define who contributed value to a business. Value can be highly subjective, especially when family and domestic dynamics are factored in. A spouse might not have a formal role in a business, but they might help build a brand, develop a product, or make key sales introductions. Their contributions could be even less formal, such as taking on a greater share of domestic work so their spouse can spend more time working on the business. Those sorts of support are a real contribution to the value of a business, and Pupica says they need to be accounted for.

If value is being formally accounted for before any potential relationship breakdown, some of the contributions that a spouse makes can be hard to assign a dollar value to. What is the value to a business in one spouse making dinner every night or doing all the childcare work. Pupica says that this can be a difficult process, but connecting those informal contributions back to what they allowed the business founder to do can help to pin down a value.

There are times, Pupica says, where the contributions are more obvious and can be assigned to a specific dollar amount, that might include helping with a proprietary technology, or making a crucial customer introduction. Pupica notes, however, that some clients might understate their contributions. She gives the example of one client who says she’s not involved at all in the business, despite introducing her husband to a customer that now represents 30 per cent of their revenue.

Formalize first, or pay later

Pupica says that business founders are far better served beginning this process of formalizing contributions as soon as possible. She says that going through this process before any relationship breakdown has occurred is also far simpler.

“When everybody’s getting along, they’re much more likely to cooperate because they’re already working towards a common goal,” she says. “When we’re going through a relationship breakdown, we’re attacking people, not positions, and that’s a very different way to argue.”

Trying to get an accurate read of value contributions in the middle of a relationship breakdown can involve each spouse taking maximalist stances. That can result in worse outcomes for the business and for the finances of both spouses, not to mention higher legal fees.

The formalization process for a couple who are still together, Pupica says, begins with outlining what everyone agreed they have contributed to the business and how those contributions will be compensated. That could involve ownership stakes, that could involve other forms of compensation. Pupica emphasizes the importance of shareholder agreements for every family she works with, alongside with marriage contracts where possible. She adds that the process should also live with the couple and formal recognitions of contributed value need to be added to over time.

For clients who have professional corporations, Pupica adds that the process can be more determined by the profession’s governing body. She notes, for example, that dentists are typically allowed to have their spouses a shareholders in the practice, while veterinarians are not. These professional governance rules can also have an impact on any succession plans for the business.

While most advisors are not trained business valuators and even raising the topic of a potential relationship breakdown can be extremely difficult, but Pupica says their relationships and understanding of the client give them a uniquely important position as the people who can initiate these conversations and build a plan that is hopefully never enacted but serves to protect the client.

“Have conversations before there’s a reason to actually have them,” Pupica says. “It doesn’t need to start with a super in-depth, detailed, granular discussion about ownership or legal documents. Instead, just ask simply ‘have you talked as a family about what everybody sees happening in the future?’ ‘Do all family members understand what their role is?’ ‘How might this change over time?’ ‘What are the kids thinking?’ ‘What if circumstances change?’ There’s just so much depending on who your client is that you can just chat with them about."

LATEST NEWS