BC court expands class action targeting RBC over closet indexing fees

The fund was 'indistinguishable from the benchmark,' expert says

BC court expands class action targeting RBC over closet indexing fees

A BC court just expanded the scope of a class action challenging RBC over mutual fund fees.

Justice Elwood of the Supreme Court of British Columbia ruled on November 3, 2026, that a certified class proceeding against RBC Global Asset Management Inc. can include two new questions - both aimed squarely at whether the fund manager earned what it charged.

The case is one of four related "closet indexing" actions in BC. The investors allege that RBC managed the Canadian Equity Fund in a way that closely tracked the S&P/TSX Capped Composite Total Return Index - the fund's benchmark - while charging management fees that imply active portfolio management. Put simply: investors say they paid for active management but got something that behaved like a cheap index fund.

Did the fund just shadow its benchmark?

The two new common issues ask whether the fund's pre-fee performance was "substantially linked" to the benchmark because of low active risk, and whether there was a "substantial risk" the fund would not outperform the benchmark after fees.

Expert evidence from an associate professor of finance at the University of Toronto's Rotman School of Management found that "nearly all the variation in the performance of the CEF over the class period can be explained by movements in the Benchmark." He regarded the fund's pre-fee performance as "economically and statistically indistinguishable from the Benchmark."

RBC's expert, a senior consultant at NERA, did not dispute the performance metrics but argued they do not prove a fund is not being actively managed. An active manager, she said, may conduct genuine research and stock selection yet still produce returns close to a benchmark.

Justice Elwood found the evidence provided "some basis in fact" for the new issues - the threshold required at the certification stage.

Regulators stayed quiet, so the court stepped in

RBC argued the questions should be left to securities regulators, not the courts. Justice Elwood rejected that, pointing to evidence that the Ontario Securities Commission conducted a "Focused Review" of actively managed mutual funds in 2015 and "did not issue any staff notice, propose any new rules, nor provide any other guidance."

Without any assurance of regulatory action or investor compensation, the court found that "awaiting some kind of action by the securities regulators which may never include any compensation to the class members is not a reasonably available alternative."

The court also rejected the argument that the investors needed to show "some evidence of illegality" at this stage, holding that they "are not required to provide evidence of illegality at the certification stage."

Justice Elwood was clear about limits: "Certifying the proposed common issues will not create a judicial requirement that all active mutual funds must maintain a certain level of active risk or outperform their benchmarks."

The fee fight ahead

The investors' damages theory uses a fee-based methodology - the difference between RBC's management fees and a representative index fund fee, calculated across unitholders based on holdings and holding periods. Justice Elwood found this workable.

RBC argued damages required examining what each investor would have done differently with better disclosure. The court disagreed, finding the claim is "that class members overpaid for the management services they received."

This case is part of a broader set of four closet indexing class actions in BC. The only one to reach trial so far - against TD Asset Management - ended with the common issues answered in the defendants' favour. In that case, the court held that the definition of closet indexing required proof of "deceit, fraud, or dishonesty." The investors in the RBC case have expressly disclaimed fraud, shifting their focus to risk disclosure and fee justification.

The underlying class action has not yet gone to trial. The related case against CIBC is under appeal.

LATEST NEWS