How Anthropic bucked negative sentiment in its IPO

CIOs outline how AI service provider succeeded, note that post-IPO pricing might not immediately reflect growth

How Anthropic bucked negative sentiment in its IPO

Anthropic managed to successfully IPO at a share price of US$83, raising over US$100 billion, and achieving a market cap of US$1.5 trillion because it grew its revenue at an incredibly rapid pace. The AI lab earned US$33.24 billion between January and September, growing its revenue by 1,200 per cent, thanks in large part to a successful focus on enterprise customers. The result has been the largest IPO in history despite negative sentiment for the AI trade in the weeks preceding Anthropic’s offering.

Elliot Johnson, CIO of Evolve ETFs, and Jason Lemire, CIO of Bold Wealth, weighed in on how Anthropic managed to succeed in its IPO and what that means for the AI trade going forward. They both emphasized the rapid earnings growth that this company has shown, noting that its continued ability to grow earnings and dominate market share will be instrumental to its future performance.

“Anthropic priced at around US$83, raised something like US$107 billion, with a US$1.5 trillion valuation. That suggests that there is strong demand. So how do we rationalize this in the context of Nvidia being down 30 per cent from its high and trading at such low multiples,” Johnson asks. “We've seen capital formation in size that has frankly been unprecedented when you consider the size of SpaceX IPO and the Anthropic IPO… In that context you have Anthropic which had something like US$40 million in revenue in 2023 and is on track to generate an estimated $37 billion in 2026. That revenue ramp has never been seen before.”

Can Anthropic sustain its growth, market share?

Much of Anthropic’s success, Johnson says, has been a result of its focus on enterprise users rather than the general public. The stickier and higher revenues that a business client provides proved far more attractive for investors and lucrative for Anthropic than individual clients who tend to prefer a free option.

Johnson believes that Claude’s leadership in the enterprise space gives it momentum similar to what Microsoft has in its Office suite of applications. As Claude hits a critical mass of adoption, with a ‘harness’ that enterprise users prefer and functions for collaboration and portability that users value, Johnson argues that Anthropic will be able to protect its market share more effectively.

Jason Lemire doesn’t see that competitive moat in the same light. He says that the way AI models are evolving and being used, the effectiveness of a new model from any provider will trump customer familiarity with their previous provider.

“I’m worried about how Anthropic fits in terms of a durable moat going forward, just because they have to spend a lot of the revenue that they’re generating on their next model,” Lemire says. “If they were to lose part of their advantage to open source, or to Gemini, or to OpenAI, then that is a huge issue.”

Despite his concerns around competitive moats, Lemire says that Anthropic’s margins and revenue growth look positive. He adds that the inclusion of Anthropic on the Nasdaq 100 should be instrumental to its performance through the rest of the year, as index inclusion creates buying pressure from passive investment funds.

What to expect from Anthropic’s stock price?

Eventual index inclusion should play a role in how Anthropic performs going forward, as should its ability to demonstrate clear and continued revenue growth. Johnson cautions that outlook, however, by noting that IPOs often have unexpected results because so many pre-IPO shareholders use this moment to create life-changing wealth. He says that the lockup schedule of this IPO might be instructive for investors, with about 20-25 per cent of Anthropic shares set to be unlocked in the next 100 days. In six months, 50 per cent of shares will be open to trade on the market, and the remaining shares will be released more than one year post-IPO.

While not every shareholder with Anthropic stock will sell, Johnson notes that for many employees and other investors, the opportunity to turn paper wealth into real millions or billions will be hard to pass up. Every share they sell will need a buyer, which might result in stock price performance that doesn’t mesh with potential revenue beats. He believes that while some people might use some idiosyncratic price movements as signals of worsening sentiment, this capital replacement dynamic post-IPO should not be understated.

Both Johnson and Lemire suggest that advisors and retail investors may be better served using index products to access both Anthropic, once it’s included in major indices, and the AI theme in general. They both believe that the AI trade will continue given the capacity for this technology to enhance productivity. They believe that investors and advisors positive on the space can take the Anthropic IPO as good news, without deviating from more diversified means of exposure to the AI trade.  

“Advisors just need to take a position and ask themselves, ‘am I comfortable with potentially dragging the market by being more diversified than just traditional indexes, or can I live with the ups and downs and the potential risk if the AI trade goes south?,” Lemire says. “For us, that's one of the big issues that we're taking position on. We believe in more diversification, but that being said we believe in the potential for AI over the years ahead.”

LATEST NEWS