The firm called it "expense absorption" - the tribunal called it self-dealing
An Ontario tribunal found a fund manager drained over $10 million from its own funds to bankroll its business.
The money trail behind "expense absorption"
The Capital Markets Tribunal issued its decision on November 9, with a panel chaired by adjudicator Andrea Burke finding that Emerge Canada Inc. made over $10 million in wire transfers from the funds it managed between July 2019 and December 2022. The firm called the practice "expense absorption." But only $2,633,552 of those withdrawals matched actual fund operating expenses - the rest went to cover the firm's own costs and those of its US affiliate, Emerge Capital Management Inc.
The firm managed a suite of ARK-branded ETFs and mutual funds that peaked at over $220 million in net asset value by December 2021. A forensic analysis presented at the hearing found that nearly 80% of all money the firm received after the funds were formed came from the funds themselves. The US affiliate, the analysis established, "did not have enough money from other sources to pay all its expenses" without the fund money flowing through Emerge Canada.
The tribunal found the withdrawals constituted "self-dealing and a self-interested transaction that put Emerge Canada's interests ahead of those of the Funds." It rejected the defence that recording withdrawals as a receivable, disclosing them in audited financial statements, and charging interest made the arrangement compliant. The panel wrote that the firm "conflated the concept of the investment fund manager assuming and paying for certain Fund expenses with the mechanism of borrowing from the Funds to actually finance the expense absorption."
When the compliance chief doesn't understand conflicts
The firm's founder held four roles simultaneously - CEO, sole shareholder, chief compliance officer, and ultimate designated person. The tribunal found she had "a complete misapprehension about what was a conflict, the nature of conflicts in fund management and the process for managing conflicts, including the purpose of an IRC." She failed to identify the receivable as either a conflict of interest or a prohibited loan and never referred it to the firm's independent review committee as required.
She also prioritized launching a new set of ESG-focused funds in 2022 using money borrowed from the existing funds, growing the receivable further - even after committing to the independent review committee that the practice had stopped and the debt would be repaid by year-end.
The firm's CFO argued he was a subordinate who signed off on transfers only because internal processes required dual signatures. The tribunal rejected that defence, finding he "ought not to have simply deferred" to the CEO's decisions. His admission that he had raised concerns was, the tribunal wrote, "actually inculpatory, rather than exculpatory" - it showed he knew about the conduct yet continued to participate.
The oversight committee walks free
The regulator had also alleged that the firm's three independent review committee members breached securities law by failing to recommend action on the conflict. But the tribunal found the firm never completed a proper conflict referral - it never identified a conflict, never proposed a course of action, and never submitted the written template its own policies required. That meant the committee's legal obligations were never triggered.
The funds were delisted in October 2023 and terminated by December that year. The firm's registration was suspended in February 2024. As of December 29, 2023, the outstanding receivable stood at $4,694,813.49. A sanctions and costs hearing is pending, with the tribunal directing the parties to arrange a case management hearing by November 20, 2026.