He called them a loan, the regulator called them compensation for losses topping $10 million
Arthur Silber, a Registered Representative with CIRO and its predecessors since October 1979, agreed to a $100,000 fine and a three-year prohibition on approval in any capacity after admitting he wrote one client 13 cheques totalling $4.73m and entered 1,318 trades in that client’s accounts without specific authorization.
A Canadian Investment Regulatory Organization hearing panel accepted the settlement on November 4, covering conduct in the Montréal area of Québec.
Silber was registered with CIBC World Markets Inc. from January 1990 to June 2023, according to the agreed facts.
He has not been registered with any CIRO dealer member since June 16, 2023, and CIRO states he is not currently registered in the securities industry in any capacity.
He had no prior disciplinary history with CIRO or its predecessors.
From June 2021 to December 2022, Silber gave a client identified in the settlement only as JK at least 13 cheques totalling $4.73m.
Individual amounts ran from $95,000 to $1m, and a $97,500 cheque dated June 1, 2022 was returned NSF.
Silber tried to present the payments as a loan, but the cheques in fact compensated losses incurred by the client in accounts Silber handled, the agreed facts record.
JK’s losses in his margin accounts exceeded $10m over 2021 and 2022.
Client profile updates completed in 2019 and 2021 listed JK as born in 1950, working as a doctor, with investment knowledge listed as “good”, stated total annual income of $250,000, and liquid assets and net fixed assets estimated at $4m and $1m respectively.
Silber and JK have since agreed on compensation for the losses.
Silber entered 1,318 trades in JK’s margin accounts from September 2020 to December 2022.
The accounts were not approved as discretionary accounts.
He admitted he did not seek specific authorization from JK for each trade and exercised discretion for most of the trades entered.
The personal financial dealings contravened Dealer Member Rule 43 before January 1, 2022 and Investment Dealer Rule 3100 after that date.
The discretionary trading contravened Dealer Member Rule 1300.4 before January 1, 2022 and Investment Dealer Rule 3221 after it.
Alongside the fine and the prohibition, Silber agreed to submit to strict supervision for 12 months in the event of a reapproval and to pay $10,000 in costs.
The amounts are payable immediately upon acceptance unless Enforcement Staff and Silber agree otherwise.
Silber dated the agreement August 11, and Senior Enforcement Counsel Francis Larin signed for Enforcement Staff.
Enforcement Staff will not initiate further action against Silber on the agreed facts and contraventions, unless he fails to comply with the terms, in which case Enforcement Staff may bring proceedings under Investment Dealer Rule 8200.
The panel comprised chair Michel Brunet with industry members Jacques Lemay and Marie-Julie Nicolo.
CIRO says the panel’s written reasons will be made available on the regulator’s own website.