Getting ahead of the ETF curve

Getting ahead of the ETF curve

Getting ahead of the ETF curve

“That’s important in volatile markets because you want to know what you own so that you know where you are vulnerable. With mutual funds you don’t know what you own until it’s usually too late.”
He suggests that level of knowledge of a client’s exposure to Canadian bank stocks, for example, would be in short supply were a mortgage crisis to occur, causing the stock’s value to drop. “You would have to guess your exposure,” says Yamada.
That kind of analysis has traditionally rubbed “mutual fund” advisors the wrong way, but a surprising number tell WP that they see the market moving in the direction of ETFs and they are actively tweaking their own models to accommodate those clients looking for a fee system.

Those commission advisors are also conceding that the enhanced liquidity of ETFs is another feature attracting their customers.
“There is less liquidity in a mutual fund than an exchange-traded fund,” says Tabet. “ETFs have intra-day liquidity, which means I can buy and sell it during the day, whereas a mutual I can only buy and sell once a day, at closing.”
Still, they also point to enough potential disadvantages to ETFs — intraday pricing issues, unfavourable bid-ask spreads, the higher management costs for ETFs over regular stocks, etc. — as support for the idea that mutual funds will continue to offer a fair return for their clients even with or without the loss of embedded commissions and the typically higher MERs of mutual funds.

Yamada may not buy it.

He points to the early adopters of ETFs — CEOs of major companies who felt they were the cheapest, most cost-effective way of getting access to broad markets.

The same will happen with advisors and wealth management professionals, he predicts. Still all may not be rosy in the ETF future Tabet sees. It’s why wealth professionals have to work more diligently to make these funds easier to understand and have to do a better job of educating clients, he says.

Related Stories:

A falling loonie hasn’t lifted all Canadian ETFs

Cheap ETFs put pressure on Canada: Toronto advisor

ETF growth set to accelerate - study

read more > 1 2

  • Kevin O'Brien 2014-04-29 1:14:20 PM
    As with all investments do your due diligence Some are comparing apples and oranges. With an ETF you are buying an index...does anyone know what happened to the Canadian index when Nortel dropped? or 2008? If you owned the index you lost permanently.
    Post a reply
  • Sean Straughan 2014-04-29 2:02:06 PM
    Most of the negativity being directed towards the use of ETF's for long term investing seems to be coming from Mutual Find companies, who are seeing their share of the fee wallet shrinking or from transaction based advisor's who can't DSC ETF's. I agree with Kevin, do your research. I am sure a number of mutual fund managers were in love with Nortel and could not sell their shares fast enough to exit. If a mutual fund is too large, I have been told it can take up to 240 days to clear a position fully.
    Post a reply