A new poll by the Canadian Federation of Independent Business (CFIB) has found nearly three quarters (72%) of small-business owners plan to exit their business within the next ten years. That will put $1.5 trillion in business assets in play — but a concerning number of retiring entrepreneurs don’t have a game plan yet.
According to the CFIB, just 49% of business owners have a succession plan; only 8% have a formal written plan. Among owners with shorter exit timelines (12 months or less), 21% have a formal plan; that percentage declines to 10% among those exiting in the next one to five years, and falls further to 6% among those with a six- to ten-year timeline.
When asked why they planned to exit, 81% of respondents cited retirement, while another 12% said they have not found a suitable successor. Plans to move on to another business venture figured in the decision for 9%, most of whom were under 50 years old.
“With many baby boomers planning to retire in the coming years, business succession is a major concern,” said Corinne Pohlmann, CFIB senior vice-president of national affairs. “We need to do everything possible to ease the transition."
A smooth transition might be hard to manage, however. When it comes to succession planning, the main hurdle cited by survey respondents was finding a suitable successor (56%). Small-business owners also cited barriers such as difficulty in valuing the business (48%), too much dependence on their active involvement (40%), and securing financing for the successor (37%).
Selling to unrelated third parties is on the minds of nearly half of business owners (48%). Another 25% are considering selling to employees, while the same proportion of respondents may sell to family members. Other exit methods cited were a transfer to family members through inheritance (21%) and winding down the business (15%).
Why are more small-business owners considering a sale to a third party than selling to a family member? Taxes may play a role. The CFIB noted that currently, the difference between the sale price of a business and the price originally paid is taxed as a dividend for those who sell to a family member. But when the business is sold to an unrelated person, it’s considered a capital gain, which makes it eligible for a lifetime capital gains exemption (LCGE).
“Under the current rules, business owners pay higher taxes when they sell to a family member than when they sell to a stranger,” Pohlmann said. “It doesn't make sense.”
Because many small-business owners derive retirement income from the sale of their business, the CFIB also urged governments to raise the LCGE threshold to $1 million for all small- and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs), not just farmers and fishermen. As for the transfer of a business to the owner’s children, it recommended that small corporations be allowed to defer the tax on the resulting capital gains.
Follow WP on Facebook, LinkedIn and Twitter
Morneau unveils business tax break, welcomed by CFIB
Ontario scraps extra tax on passive investment income
More market talk: